The Coronavirus Shows: It is Time to De-Privatize U.S. Healthcare
Recently, in southeastern Indiana, several workers in the hospitality industry gathered to talk about their health. A cook in her sixties shared how she had gone months without her asthma inhalers because she couldn’t afford them. During that period, she was taken to the hospital by ambulance twice. A restaurant server talked about not being able to pay for tests her doctor recommended for potentially cancerous breast tissue. Another has seven prescriptions and tearfully described the perpetual calculation about which to fill, because she can’t come close to affording them all.
Each story was greeted by sad, knowing nods. Several workers spoke about skipping doctor visits, reluctant to add to the stack of unpaid medical bills already piling up on their kitchen tables.
Beyond their inability to get the care they need, they had another thing in common: All had health insurance.
At least, they had what often passes for health insurance in the United States. Unique among other nations, we prioritize the interests of corporations making billions of dollars in healthcare profits over the goal of ensuring access to care for all. While twenty-seven million Americans have no health insurance at all, four in ten working Americans have a high-deductible plan that forces them to pay thousands of dollars out of pocket before they get any benefit from the premiums taken out of their paychecks each week.
Reams of academic medical studies confirm what the workers in Indiana tell us: price tag barriers to accessing healthcare deter people from seeking the care they need. As recently as last month, most Americans may have seen this as only a problem for the worker who could not afford to see a doctor about her high blood pressure or diabetes. This month, we know it is a problem for all of us. That same worker is unlikely to seek testing and treatment for the coronavirus, which means they may unknowingly spread it. “The reality is, there are a lot of people that are thinking, ‘I don’t want a couple-thousand-dollar bill to get tested or to get treated,’” California congressional representative Ro Khanna told the Huffington Post, “That’s going to hurt all of us.”
Americans’ financial fears are well-founded. Although Donald Trump in a primetime television address claimed that health insurance companies had agreed to waive copays for coronavirus treatment, those companies quickly walked it back. They were waiving copays for testing only, not treatment. And that treatment could be enormously expensive. As the New York Times reported, a father and young daughter quarantined after coronavirus exposure already face “a pile of medical bills” adding up to $3,918.
We don’t have to guess at the damage caused by financial barriers to care. A Harvard Medical School study showed that 45,000 people in the U.S. die each year because of lack of healthcare coverage. In the case of an aggressive infectious disease like the coronavirus, where lack of testing and treatment will impact others, that total could mushroom.
Those who do seek testing will have a hard time finding it. The United States lags far behind nations like South Korea in providing access to the tests that would spur quarantines and slow the spread of the disease. “That is a failing. Let’s admit it,” Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, told Congress when responding to questions about the lack of tests. At the same time, U.S. hospitals forced to focus on revenue margins and hampered by a reduction in federal emergency funding don’t have adequate beds and supplies such as ventilators.
This level of unpreparedness may seem remarkable, given that we in the United States spend far more per capita on healthcare than any other nation in history. Yet, unlike every other nation, we waste a breathtaking $500 billion each year in healthcare money spent not on care, but on private insurance corporations’ shareholder returns, executive pay as high as $83 million per year, and a massive bureaucracy devoted to contesting insurance claims and marketing. Not to mention the billions diverted to pharmaceutical corporation profits by refusing to negotiate the cost of medicines paid by our Medicare system. [AU: Can you rephrase? I assume you mean the government’s refusal to negotiate for lower rates, but it’s not clear who’s refusing.]
The problem is clear. We have allowed the profit motive to drive our U.S. healthcare system, and it has driven us straight into a ditch.
An Opportunity for Fundamental Reform
The surrender of our healthcare system to profiteering interests is so profound that the medical qualifications of our nation’s top health official, Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, feature his work as chief lobbyist for a pharma corporation that tripled the price of insulin during his tenure. Azar has refused to promise Congress that Americans will be able to access any coronavirus vaccine because, well, profit: “We would want to ensure that we work to make it affordable, but we can’t control that price because we need the private sector to invest,” he said . “The priority is to get vaccines and therapeutics and price controls won’t get us there.”
But Secretary Azar is wrong, and he knows it. Taxpayers, not the private sector, are the most important sponsors of medicines medical research, including groundbreaking research on cancer, heart disease, and infectious diseases. The coronavirus research is no exception: As a recent report by Public Citizen shows, the National Institutes of Health has shouldered the responsibility for developing new treatments and vaccines against COVID-19. Yet the customary next step in the modern U.S. medicines [AU: Do you mean medical?] system is to hand over the fruits of public research to private corporations in the form of monopoly patents that last 20 years and longer, which set the stage for price-gouging. Azar seems intent on following this script with any coronavirus vaccine, too.
The same Americans who would struggle to pay for a vaccine or treatment are also likely to be among the 70% of low-wage workers who have no paid sick leave. That means that, even if they are not feeling well, they will feel profound financial pressure to show up for work in nursing homes, restaurants, and grocery stores. Mandatory sick- pay legislation that is the norm in other nations has been blocked for decades in the U.S.United States, yet another sacrifice of public health at the altar of private profit.
We can do better, and we must. Fortunately, the coronavirus scare may be opening up some eyes to this reality. Even Congressional and administration Republicanscongressional and administration Republicans long opposed too government healthcare are talking about copay waivers and government guarantees of coronavirus treatment. As the New York Times’s Farhad Manjoo wrote, “Everyone is a socialist in a pandemic.”
Even before the pandemic, Americans consistently cited the prescription- drug pricing crisis as the number one issue they want lawmakers to address. And there is an enduring global legacy of treating essential medicines as a public good, not a commodity for profiteering. Until corporate-pushed reforms in the late 20th century, virtually every nation on earth prohibited patenting or otherwise monopolizing access to life-essential medicines. As Jonas Salk said when asked if he considered monopolizing the polio vaccine, “Could you patent the sun?” I have written in detail about the case for removing profiteering and monopolies from the already government-subsidized prescription medicines process.
And there is strong support for a full public healthcare system that eliminates the barriers of copays and deductibles, and ensures coverage for all. Opinion polls show strong support for Medicare for All proposals, coupled with deep frustration with insurance companies. Democratic Party voters in every primary state so far have expressed preference for a single-payer government healthcare system.
The faith community, with our its extensive legacy of providing direct healthcare and deep scriptural commitment to universal care, should be leading this call for fundamental reform. The fear and dysfunction associated with the coronavirus pandemic are unspeakably horrific, but they could spur the U.S.United States to once and for all to remove profiteering from our healthcare system.
DSA member Fran Quigley is director of the Health and Human Right Clinic at Indiana University McKinney School of Law and editor of the weekly Faith in Healthcare newsletter. This article also appears in Sojo.net and at religiousssocialism.org