A Note on Joe Hill


Joe Hill/Franklin Rosemont

By Paul Buhle

Franklin Rosemont’s Joe Hill, appearing in 2003 from the venerable Charles H. Kerr Company (best known as publisher of revolutionary socialist books and the International Socialist Review magazine, way back in the 1910s), and reprinted in 2015 by PM Press, should be remembered as leading example of an autodidact author’s treatment of a great American martyr. So I mean to write about the writer as well as the subject.

Amid the artistic-political fringe of the Chicago Left from the middle 1960s until his death, Rosemont inherited the rich legacy of the IWW autodidacts (the “Hobo College”) and their successors in the Dil Pickle Club and the College of Complexes, running into the end of the 1950s. It was a working class, rebel bohemianism, loosely attached to Blues, Jazz, Studs Terkel and a string of radical personalities, notably if not only literary ones, Richard Wright and Nelson Algren among them. Rosemont himself, son of a Typographers’ Union leader who guided the famed 1949 Chicago newspaper strike, grew up and lived within this world, knew the aging Wobbly officers and local members of the 1950s-60s intimately, and took over the Kerr Company from the Proletarian Party and a successor who had kept it going, if barely, since the IWW decline. The other books published by the Kerr Company, from the 1980s, dealt heavily in that unique Chicago history, a significant chunk of midwesternisms little understood “East of the Hudson,” in New York literary circles.

Like Johnny Appleseed, another enigmatic American radical icon, Joe Hill is known mostly by reputation. A Swedish immigrant and Wobbly enthusiast, he rambled, he wrote immortal song lyrics satirizing capitalism and calling for rebellion and…he died a martyr, to a Utah government firing squad. Of the intimate details of Hill’s life, precious little was recorded or has been recovered, perhaps because he gloried at being a rank-and-filer or perhaps because he kept a fairly low profile. Did he refuse to save himself from a false murder charge by assuring his lover (someone else’s wife) that she should not testify to his presence during the crime? We’ll never know.

For Rosemont, these kinds of details miss the main point. The old IWW, epitomized and thematized by Hill in his songs and his attitude toward existing laws, contained a working class culture of its very own, outside the bounds of capitalist rules but also outside the bounds of nearly anything else on the Left. Hill and the Wobs refused the very logic of production and consumption under the wage system. They did not see contemporary capitalism, advancing into every corner of life, as promoting progress toward anything, and in that way, Hill stood miles apart from the mainstream of the Second International and most contemporary assumptions of socialists. In our current moment of ecological catastrophe, the case can be argued again.

But there is something more to be said in the Hill’s use of humor to attack the system--the IWW’s adoption of popular culture, vaudeville music to contemporary comic strip styles--as a way to reach ordinary folks. We do not need to imagine what a modern Joe Hill would do with social media, because so many of the facebook political postings during the last year have been so funny and so insightful. My own thoughts went back to Joe Hill when, in Wisconsin of 2011-12, rank and file jokers brought new funny signs to the massive demonstrations day after day, ridiculing conservatives but also conservative union leaders, and accepting congratulation on all sides for coming up with fresh gags.

We need more Joe Hills in the socialist present and future but, with luck, and with bright young socialists bitterly hostile toward capitalism and its politicians, we may have them.

Paul Buhle has turned to publishing comics during the last decade but his many books include It Started In Wisconsin, co-edited with Mari Jo Buhle: A Documentation of Our Struggle.

Individually signed posts do not necessarily reflect the views of DSA as an organization or its leadership. Democratic Left blog post submission guidelines can be found here.


DSA Immigration Rights Rapid Response: #AbolishICE

June 21, 2018

Thursday, June 21st at 8:30pm ET/7:30pm CT/6:30pm MT/5:30pm PT

Sign up here for a link to the call RSVP.

The Trump administration’s policy of separating families seeking asylum is only the latest in a escalation of anti-immigrant policies. We need to #AbolishICE now. Join us for an emergency call with the national DSA Immigrant Rights committee and our allies to discuss our strategy.

If you cannot make this call, please sign up here for a call recording and more organizing resources.

New Member Call, June 24

June 24, 2018

9pm ET/8 CT/7 MT/6 PT

Click to RSVP

You've joined DSA - Great! Now register for this New Member Orientation call and find out more about our politics and our vision. And, most importantly, how you can become involved.

Questions or Comments? Contact: 

Sam M

Click to RSVP

**Note: this page originally had the wrong date listed. The Correct date is Sunday the 24th**

M4A Chapter Activist Training Call: How to Pass a Medicare for All City Council Resolution

June 30, 2018

Saturday June 30th at 4pm ET/3pm CT/2pm MT/1pm PST

Click Here to RSVP

In March, Philadelphia DSA members showed up in droves with healthcare workers, community members, and elected leaders to pass a Philadelphia city-wide resolution supporting the Medicare for All Act of 2017 and affirming universal access to healthcare as a human right. This victory showed that in a city where the poverty rate is over 26%, city council leaders learned where to stand when it comes to universal healthcare. To move a national campaign to win Medicare for All, we need to build support from a broad range of cities and municipalities across the country. With some research, planning, and lobbying, you could work with city council members to pass a resolution of support in your city too!

Click Here to RSVP